Cremating or Burying Your Cat: Pros, Cons, and Considerations

When your cat passes away, deciding what to do next can be overwhelming. As we provide aftercare to dying pets, we also give pet owners support on cremation and burial options, empowering them to make a choice that brings peace. Learn about pet cremation and burial for cats to decide which one would work better for your circumstances.

Is It Better to Cremate or Bury a Cat?

When deciding between cremation and burial for your cat, both options offer significant ways to give your pet a final resting place and get a sense of closure during a difficult time. Cremation provides flexibility, letting you keep your cat’s ashes close. Burial offers a permanent resting place where you can visit, creating a tangible memorial site.

A woman cradles a cat against a vibrant sunset backdrop

Deciding between cremation and burial for your cat is a deeply personal choice, each offering distinct ways to honor their memory. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your preferences, living situation, budget, and what feels most meaningful for your cat’s life.

Pet Cat Cremation

Aquamation (also known as water cremation) and what we offer here at Paws into Grace, gently immerses the deceased pet’s body in a warm solution of water and alkaline chemicals, accelerating the natural decomposition process and leaving behind sterile bone fragments. Fire Cremation, on the other hand, places the body into a specialized chamber where temperatures reach extremely high levels.

Benefits

  • Portability: Cremated remains are easily transportable, making them ideal for owners who may move in the future.
  • Memorialization flexibility: Ashes can be scattered, kept in an urn, incorporated into jewelry, or placed in a columbarium.
  • No land requirement: Cremation eliminates the need for a designated burial plot.

Downsides

  • Absence of a burial site: For some, the lack of a tangible grave to visit can lengthen the grieving process.
  • Emotional detachment (for some): The process of cremation itself, and the reduction of a beloved pet to ashes, can feel emotionally distant for certain individuals.

Applicable Situations

Weigh in these situations where cremation can be a more suitable option for your cat.

  • When you rent or live in an apartment: Without private land for burial, cremation offers a respectful and legal alternative.
  • When you anticipate moving frequently: The portability of ashes allows pet parents to keep their pet’s remains with them regardless of their location.
  • When you desire creative memorialization options: From scattering ashes in a favorite spot to incorporating them into a piece of art, cremation offers diverse ways to remember a pet.

Pet Cat Burial

Burial involves placing the deceased cat’s body directly into the ground. The grave should be deep enough to prevent disturbance by other animals, and the location must adhere to any local ordinances regarding burying pet remains. You can mark the burial site with a headstone, plaque, or memorial garden.

Benefits

  • Tangible memorial site: A physical grave provides a specific place for you to visit, mourn, and remember your pet.
  • Sense of closure: For some, the act of burial provides a more definitive sense of closure and a traditional farewell.
  • Connection to nature: Burying a pet in the earth can feel like a natural return to the cycle of life.

A collection of four key chains, each adorned with unique decorative charms

Downsides

  • Land requirement and regulations: Not every place permits home burial, and even where allowed, specific depth and distance regulations may apply.
  • Potential for disturbance: Without proper depth and protection, a buried pet’s remains could be disturbed by wildlife.

Note: Pentobarbital, the medication commonly used in pet euthanasia, remains in the animal’s body long after passing. When a pet is buried after euthanasia, there is a risk that this chemical can leach into the soil and contaminate groundwater, especially if the burial site is shallow or located near a water source. Even small amounts of pentobarbital can be harmful to wildlife, scavenging animals, and the environment. For this reason, many veterinarians and environmental experts recommend cremation or aquamation as safer alternatives to home burial.

Applicable Situations

These situations can help determine whether pet burial is a better option for your needs.

  • When you desire a permanent memorial: A grave site serves as a physical marker and a dedicated space for remembrance.
  • When you want to find comfort in traditional rituals: The act of burial aligns with long-standing human practices of laying loved ones to rest.
  • When you want to keep the remains close: Knowing your pet is buried on your property can provide ongoing comfort and a feeling of continued presence.

Differences Between Cremation and Burial for Pet Cats

Pet cremation and pet burial offer very different experiences and outcomes for your cat’s final arrangements. Here is a table that highlights some main differences:

FactorCremationBurial
Final remainsAshes and bone fragmentsDecomposing body (eventually skeleton)
CostOften less expensiveDepending on burial site
Space neededNo land neededNeeds a burial plot or private land
TimingFlexibleNeeds to be done soon after passing
MemorializationMany portable options (urns, jewelry, scattering)Physical grave or marker to visit
Environmental impactAquamation is eco-friendlyIf the cat has been euthanized, there is risk of pentobarbital leaking into ground water
RegulationsFew legal issuesLocal laws may restrict home burial

Factors to Consider When Deciding Between Burial and Cremation for Cats

Pet burial and cremation are each options with unique qualities, so take the time to consider what matters most to you and your family.

  • Space and Location: Pet burial often needs a permanent spot, like a yard or a pet cemetery. If you rent or plan to move, pet cremation is more portable, and you can keep your cat’s ashes with you.
  • Emotional Needs: You might find comfort in having a physical grave to visit. Others may prefer keeping an urn or using the ashes for jewelry, which can feel more personal.
  • Costs: Private cremation with a decorative urn can be costly, as can a plot and headstone in a pet cemetery. Home burial might be the most economical, although it requires suitable land and adherence to regulations.

A white box featuring a wooden plaque affixed to its surface

Related Questions

What Are Ways to Memorialize Your Cat?

To memorialize your cat, you can keep their ashes in a special urn or incorporate them into beautiful jewelry or ornaments. Some pet parents also opt for a private viewing before cremation to say their final goodbyes.

Are Most Pets Cremated or Buried?

Cremation has become the more prevalent choice for most pet parents due to its various options. In 2024, the pet cremation rate in the U.S. stood at 61.8%, with projections showing an increase to 67.9% by 2029. California leads the nation in pet cremation, with 69.1% of pet owners in the state choosing this option.

What Are My Options When Cats Are Nearing the End of Life?

When cats are nearing the end of life, options typically include palliative care for comfort or compassionate in-home pet euthanasia to prevent further suffering. These choices enable you to prioritize your cat’s well-being during their final moments.

Conclusion

When it comes to cremating or burying a cat, the most fitting choice is influenced by individual circumstances, emotional needs, and practical considerations. We offer empathetic guidance and comprehensive information to make a decision that will bring you peace during a time of immense sorrow.

Dr. Benson started Paws into Grace in 2007. She wanted to give pets and their parents a beautiful last encounter that didn't have to be in an unfamiliar office where pets were often frightened. The empathy she shows each family creates a lasting impression on them. In her free time, Dr. Benson enjoys running and spending time with her family, dogs, cats, and chickens.

  

Testimonials

I can't recommend them enough. I had to say goodbye to my 21 year old cat companion. I read the reviews here on Yelp and chose Paws Into Grace and they made an unbearable situation not worse - from the people on the phone to the amazing doctor who... read more

Renee C.

My absolute love Dante had heart failure three months ago. After having him on many medications to help him, his enthusiasm and appetite declined last couple of days. He was in pain and we decided to help him go to heaven rather than torturing him... read more

Diane C.

I wanted to thank you for sending Dr. Brown to euthanize our beloved Myleigh on March 4, 2021. She was compassionate and accommodating, she explained every step of the procedure, and gave us some alone time with Myleigh after she sedated her, but... read more

Terry A.

Renee C.

I can't recommend them enough. I had to say goodbye to my 21 year old cat companion. I read the reviews here on Yelp and chose Paws Into Grace and they made an unbearable situation not worse - from the people on the phone to the amazing doctor who came out to the house. She was so understanding and supportive. They were all so helpful, understanding and nice. My girl got to stay at home and say goodbye in the backyard (a hummingbird flew over and it seemed like a good sign too). So glad I didn't have to take her to a cold vet office.

Diane C.

My absolute love Dante had heart failure three months ago. After having him on many medications to help him, his enthusiasm and appetite declined last couple of days. He was in pain and we decided to help him go to heaven rather than torturing him with more medications which would make him even more miserable. I called and spoke to a very kind lady who was patient as I cried through making an appointment. We made an appointment for 1:30pm. Dr. Toni arrived. She was very kind, explained everything to us and gave us the time to be with our boy after the first shot. He wasn't relaxing enough so she gave him a second shot. We stayed with him throughout the entire process and I carried him to her car in the end. It was a very difficult decision but knowing that our boy is not in pain, gives us some peace. We are thankful to Dr. Toni for her kindness and compassion. They will arrange the cremation for us. Since we are in a pandemic, we had our masks on and said goodbye to our boy in our garden.

Terry A.

I wanted to thank you for sending Dr. Brown to euthanize our beloved Myleigh on March 4, 2021. She was compassionate and accommodating, she explained every step of the procedure, and gave us some alone time with Myleigh after she sedated her, but before she attached the IV. We were relieved that we made the decision to let her go to doggy heaven at home. It was a tranquil and serene passing for her, and it very much aids us in the grieving and healing process knowing that she passed away so peacefully. Based on the grace and compassion Dr. Brown demonstrated on one of the most awful days of our lives we would not hesitate to recommend Paws Into Grace for others facing this very painful time.
San Diego Orange County Cremation Office